What Is the Sugar Diet? Benefits, Risks & Scientific Insights

Despite the name, the sugar diet isn’t about eating candy all day.

Prefer to listen without the ads? Become a Ben Bikman Insider.

What Is the Sugar Diet?

Despite the name, the sugar diet isn’t about eating candy all day. It emphasizes simple carbohydrates from sources like fruits, fruit juices, and honey, while dramatically limiting protein and fat—each typically under 10% of total calories. Advocates report fat loss, increased energy, and physical performance, though scientific studies on the diet itself are lacking. Interestingly, it shares many features with the 1930s rice diet used to treat heart and kidney disease, which also emphasized high-carb, low-fat, and low-protein eating.

Can High Sugar Diets Improve Metabolism?

At first glance, the sugar diet flies in the face of metabolic science. Yet, multiple studies suggest there could be short-term benefits—especially among lean, highly active men. For instance, a 2016 animal study showed that a low-protein, high-carb diet improved insulin sensitivity and glucose control, even with a high sugar load. Similarly, a 2022 human trial found that reducing protein (without restricting calories) produced similar benefits as traditional calorie restriction—including fat loss and improved insulin sensitivity.

Protein Restriction and FGF21: The Real Mechanism?

So how is this possible? It appears the real key is protein restriction, not sugar. Multiple studies have shown that limiting protein intake dramatically boosts fibroblast growth factor 21 (FGF21), a liver hormone that:

Enhances insulin sensitivity
Promotes mitochondrial biogenesis
Stimulates energy-burning mitochondrial uncoupling
May even extend lifespan (in mice)

A 2025 study published in Nature Metabolism showed that healthy lean men on a low-protein diet had to eat 20% more calories just to maintain their weight—while still losing fat mass. FGF21 levels rose by over 360%, a rare metabolic response in humans.

Is the Sugar Diet Right for Everyone?

Probably not. Anecdotal reports of success are almost entirely from very lean, physically active men. This group is already insulin sensitive and more likely to tolerate high sugar loads without immediate metabolic damage. However, for people with insulin resistance, addictive eating behaviors, or poor satiety control, a high-sugar, low-protein diet could backfire. Concerns include:

Lack of fiber and essential amino acids
Increased hunger and food cravings
Potential for binge cycles in susceptible individuals
Absence of long-term safety data

There’s also little evidence that women respond as well to the diet—an imbalance reflected in both studies and anecdotal reports.

In Summary...

The sugar diet may be less about sugar and more about what it’s lacking: protein. By restricting protein, the body triggers hormonal and mitochondrial responses that may improve fat loss and energy use—at least in the short term. But without long-term data or personalized assessment, it’s a risky strategy for most. For now, a better takeaway may be to study the power of protein restriction more carefully before jumping on the sugar train.

10-Day Free Trial!

Start your journey toward better health today by taking control of your metabolic future, with the support you need for success.

The information on this blog is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of qualified health providers with questions you may have regarding medical conditions.