Prefer to listen without the ads? Become a Ben Bikman Insider.
Hormones, Not Calories, Determine Fat Storage
For decades, the mainstream narrative has pointed to overeating as the primary cause of obesity. But rare genetic disorders tell a different story. Conditions like leptin deficiency, POMC deficiency, and MC4R mutations show that even when calorie intake remains constant, fat accumulation can be extreme. These forms of monogenic obesity highlight the decisive role hormones—especially insulin—play in determining how the body stores or burns energy.
In all of these conditions, the body receives distorted or absent hormonal signals, leading to excessive insulin secretion. Elevated insulin levels shift energy toward fat storage, regardless of how much is being eaten. These disorders provide compelling evidence that obesity is a condition of hormonal mismanagement, not just caloric imbalance.
The POMC Pathway: Master Regulator of Appetite and Energy
At the heart of this story lies the hypothalamus, where a critical pathway involving POMC (pro-opiomelanocortin) plays a central role in regulating hunger, metabolism, and fat storage. When functioning properly, this pathway helps the body balance energy use and hunger. But when genes in the POMC pathway are defective, the results can be devastating—severe hunger, low energy use, and runaway fat accumulation.
Importantly, individuals with POMC-related disorders often consume the same number of calories as those without the condition, yet gain significantly more fat. This occurs not because they eat more, but because their bodies are programmed to store more. Even subtle disruptions in this hormonal circuit can lead to insulin resistance and metabolic dysfunction.
Leptin and MC4R: Gatekeepers of Fat Storage
Leptin deficiency offers another striking example. This hormone, produced by fat cells, is supposed to signal the brain that energy stores are full. Without leptin, the brain never gets the memo and keeps the body in fat-gathering mode. Leptin-deficient individuals also exhibit high insulin levels, which directly promote fat gain.
MC4R (melanocortin 4 receptor) mutations—one of the most common forms of monogenic obesity—further underscore this point. Even when MC4R is only partially functional, fat storage increases dramatically. The common thread? All of these genetic pathways converge on elevated insulin, confirming that this hormone is the final switch in the fat-storage process.
What This Means for Everyone Else
While these genetic conditions are rare, they shed light on more common metabolic struggles. Many people experience chronically high insulin levels due to diet, stress, or other lifestyle factors—without any genetic mutation. In this sense, the insights from monogenic obesity can help explain why so many people find it difficult to lose fat despite eating “normally.”
Rather than focusing solely on calorie intake, it may be more productive to pay attention to the hormones that control fat storage. Insulin, leptin, and signals from the hypothalamus are the true regulators of metabolic health—and understanding them could reshape the way we approach obesity.
10-Day Free Trial!
Start your journey toward better health today by taking control of your metabolic future, with the support you need for success.